1. Jaclyn

    Thank you so much for this article. There are so many options and talk out there it’s hard to know what is the best for what I need. You make it so easy to understand and I’ve learned a lot from you. Thank you for sharing your knowledge!

    1. McKenzie Pinckney

      That’s so great! I’m glad it was informative and helpful 🙂

    2. Valerie dreher

      Wow. Great read. I didn’t realize we exhaust our carb and fat supply everyday.

    3. Lara

      I am very active and yet I have very little muscle. I know now that I need Ideal Lean to help me achieve my goals!

    4. Shar

      Now I can finally understand the difference. The only problem is that I love, love, love the chocolate peanut butter meal replacement and would love to have it every time for every thing. Any chance you can add that flavor to your other lines?

      1. Caitlin Peterson

        That is a great suggestion! I love that flavor also. 🙂

  2. margie

    so if i am understanding this article correctly, i have been on ideal shake for almost 3 yrs, lost and now maintaining but would like to loose alittle more. i go to weight and cardio classes for about an hr 4 days a week, as well as having an active lifestyle. so at this point is your article suggesting that i switch to ideal lean meal replacement to meet my goals

    1. McKenzie Pinckney

      Margie, if you’re consistently active, I think you’d really benefit from using the Fit line products. The increase in protein will help you build lean muscle mass, which will help you lose excess fat. I think it’s worth trying! If you’ve like the IdealShake, you’ll definitely love IdealLean 🙂

      1. margi

        so i have alot of idealshape to use, recently got an order. what do you suggest to ramp up the necessary components of my current shakes to use them up before i can order idealfit meal replacement shakes? can i add idealfit protein to my current shakes?

        1. McKenzie Pinckney

          Oh you’re fine to still use the IdealShake. If fact, Trainer Kami incorporates the Shake into her diet and uses Fit line products too. I would just use up what you have and either order when you’ve exhausted it, or go ahead and order some protein now.

    2. Angelina Velasquez

      I am trying to building’s lean muscle I do free weights and HIT what should I be taking please let me ..thanks

      1. Caitlin Peterson

        Hi! I recommend using IdealLean products since you are trying to build lean muscle! You should definitely use IdealLean Protein and IdealLean BCAAs, then if you need a quick meal on the go you can take IdealLean Meal Replacement Shakes.

  3. Christine

    you can still use the Ideal lean protein powder as a meal replacement as long as combined with a fat and carb, right? even if it’s not around workout time?

  4. Trisha Taylor

    Which which? 😊 I am looking to lose about 20-25lbs. I am an ER nurse so I walk about 10k steps 4x a week and I work out 4-5 times a week at Orangetheory. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!! Trying to work off baby weight #3.

    1. McKenzie Pinckney

      Hi Trish! So, you would be a great candidate for either Shape or Fit products. Because you’re active, I almost lean a bit more towards our IdealLean line, which will help you build up lean muscle mass to help you lose that excess weight. I would start with using our IdealLean Whey Protein and Meal Replacement. I think you’ll really enjoy them 🙂

  5. Shay R

    I really purchased the IdealFit protein powder as well as the meal replacement. I work out 6 days a week and I’m looking to lose weight but after more research and finding that IdealFit and Idealshape are the same company, I think I may have purchased the wrong thing. So since I want to lose weight is the IdealFit meal replacement not the right product?

    1. McKenzie Pinckney

      Hi Shay! If you’re currently active 6 days a week, you’ll actually be just fine using the Fit products. Shape is more for people who aren’t very active, and it sounds like you are.

  6. Evetta gray

    So if I am doing kick boxing three days a week its my first time doing this type of exercise. I been doing it for 2 weeks four days which ideal product should I take and I am diabetic but not takeing any medicine at all. Evettagray51@gmail.com

    1. McKenzie Pinckney

      Hi Evetta! As long as you continue an active lifestyle, the Fit products will be great for you. Now, make sure any changes in your diet are followed up with your physician, because diabetes is a tricky disease we don’t want to anger.

  7. Laura

    I’m not sure if my activity level is sufficient to classify as ” moderate”. I walk 10,000- 13,000 steps at least 5 days a week but only get to do a formal workout 1-2 times a week. I am looking to lose about 10lbs. Am I active enough to stop using idealshape and use the lean products?

    1. McKenzie Pinckney

      Hi Laura! I’d say you’re within the realm of moderate exercise. You would definitely benefit from using the Lean products, like the protein and the meal replacement. On the days you can get a strength training session in, make that your priority. Building lean muscle mass is essential for losing excess fat, and therefore weight. The Protein and Meal Replacement will help 🙂

  8. Kristin P

    I currently bought the 6 week challenge and I am starting soon. I can’t wait! My question is, can I incorporate my IS into this plan? I have a tons because for about a year I have been mixing IS and IF. I was using IF for before and after workout but the IS as a meal replacement. I want to order the new MRS but I want to use up my IS first. I read the article which said the IS doesnt have enough protein in it so would I just be able to add like 1/2 a scope of IF to it? Thanks so much!

    1. McKenzie Pinckney

      That’s a great question. Your macros will be off from Lindsey’s meal plan, but I think if you were to do half a scoop of the IS MRS and half a scoop of the Protein, you’d get your protein in. Then going forward, stick with Lean products, but I think you’ll be okay in the mean time using up your IS 🙂

    1. McKenzie Pinckney

      Yes you can, though the MRS has enough protein that you won’t need the Lean Protein exactly at the same time, but you can absolutely take them both in the same day.

  9. Tina

    I am currently trying to lose weight. I have alot to lose..I started walking, bike riding, and hiking regularly. Do I start with ideal shake only or should I add something else to help speed things up?

    1. Stuart Oldroyd

      Hi Tina, that’s great that you’ve started a more active lifestyle! With the demands of your exercise, I think IdealLean Meal Replacement Shake would be a great option. It has the protein your muscles will need to rebuild after exercise, along with the lean nutrition to continue to lose weight. I love the Chocolate!

      You can check it out a little bit more here: https://www.idealfit.com/meal-replacement-shakes.list

  10. Lynda Moreno- Johnson

    OK. So this is me… I would like to lose 60 pounds. I workout 4x a week. Its called mixxedfit with has a set of low to high intensity. I then between days I do a challenge or take a zumba class.
    I recently lost 27.8lbs. With help of WW. I would like to know which program I should use? I’ve tried both products and like them not. Please help me decide.

    1. Stuart Oldroyd

      Hi Lynda, congratulations that’s inspiring! With how often you’re working out, I would definitely recommend IdealFit’s IdealLean products. They’ll help you continue to lose, while helping you build lean muscle. That lean muscle will really boost your results. You should check out Trainer Lindsey’s free 15-Day Challenge! it comes with free meal plans and workouts so you can mix up your routine. And be sure to check out IdealLean Meal Replacement Shake. Good luck!

  11. Bri

    Can Ideal shake be used when preggo? I want to lose unhealthy fat. 22 weeks along

    1. Stuart Oldroyd

      Hi Bri, while many women do use IdealLean and/or IdealShake, I definitely recommend you consult with your doctor first. They’ll be able to determine what’s best for you and the little one, congrats!

  12. Shannon

    I have about 35-40 pounds to lose. I want to lose and tone. I have just started working out 5/6 days a week doing cardio and weights. Should I use IdealLean or IdealShake?

    1. Stuart Oldroyd

      Hi Shannon, congrats sounds like you’re on your way! Normally I would recommend that anyone with more than 25 lbs. to lose start with IdealShape’s IdealShake, since the lower calories and signature hunger blocker will help jump-start your weight loss. But where you’re making fitness a regular part of your lifestyle, your body may need help getting all the protein it needs to tone up, and that’s where IdealLean Meal Replacement Shake could really help you out. With 20g, in addition to healthy carbs and fats, I’d recommend it as part of your plan. Keep us posted!

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      Not currently, but that would definitely be a good thing to get in the future. Thanks for the idea.

  13. Robyn

    I have recently lost about 20 pounds through diet and exercise. I have also used the ideal shape meal replacement for breakfast (so once a day). I teach and typically get 10,000 plus steps most days of the week and go to the gym 3-5 days a week (or walk). Should I stick with the ideal shape meal replacement or switch to the ideal fit?

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      Hi Robyn, so usually we say if you have 30+ pounds to lose stick with IdealShape, then if you have less than that to lose we recommend using IdealLean. If you are active though (and it sounds like you are) we recommend using IdealLean Protein to make sure that you are getting enough protein into your diet.

  14. Jade

    I fall in between…I certainly don’t have 25 lbs to lose, but I haven’t truly been active so my body fat percentage is high for my size and weight. I think from this article I could go with either because I need to curb my cravings and start eating healthier, but my goal is to tone.

  15. Nicole Teele

    Learning the difference regarding the fat, protein and carbs between Idealshape and IdealLean MRS has been extremely helpful.. As well as these other facts “The IdealLean MRS was created for those who are active and looking for healthy food options to add into their diet. Individuals who are regularly active require more carbs, protein, and fats to help with building lean muscle mass; especially those who weight train. Why? Because lifting weights creates stress on your body, and eating a proper amount of macros is important for your recovery process and your results.”

  16. Heidi

    I learned that your products are awesome! And instead of like most brands with similar products, you focus on the education of your clients as well, not everything works for everything

  17. Krystal

    Wow! This clears up so much! I will definitely be sharing this info with my sister. We are on two different physical levels right now and I want to give her the best options for her. I love your products and they’ve helped me exceed my goals. I’d like to help her reach hers

  18. Sara Rogers

    Thank you for this article. I have been using IS MRS an think it it time to switch over. I am at goal weight, but not a breakfast person so I drink a shake, or get busy and forget to meal prep so I drink a shake. I think this would be the better option for me. Thanks!

  19. Vanessa

    Thank you for explaining the difference between the the idealshape and ideallean i have been using the ideallean protein and absolutely love it, now i learned the difference between the shake replacement and the protein shake .

  20. Nicole stokes

    This article was very informative. I was wondering what the difference between the idealshake and ideallean shake were. I learned that the ideallean shake is more for if you are already working out and don’t have more that 25 pounds to lose. It is higher in carbs, protein and fat than the idealshape shake.
    Also the ideallean protein should not be used as a meal replacement but as a supplement to help refuel muscles after a workout.

  21. Marie Coffman

    Great information! I’m active and trying to lose 5-10 pounds that has crept up. I didn’t realize I need different supplements for different goals and not all protein powders are the same. I’m on day 7 of the fifteen day challenge and have lost four pounds and am feeling great!

  22. Gigi

    I am excited to try the IdealShape then as I have been sedentary way too long and need to get myself motivated and moving. Taking my 25 year old daughter on this journey also. Looking forward to seeing our results in the coming future.

    Nice to know I need less protein, as body fat to muscle ratio is skewed in favor of body fat.
    Will have to be accountable for watching calories, fat and carb intake as well; and I certainly do not mind replacing breakfast and lunch with the IdealShake,

  23. Kelly

    Love this article! I learned so much! One important thing I learned is “when you have a slow metabolism and a high-fat, high-carb diet, your gut struggles breaking down and utilizing foods. This plays a role in insulin resistance and ultimately a slow metabolism.” This is so important to me because I never knew why I had a slow metabolism!

  24. Jami Jones

    depending on eat our goals are i.e loosing 25 plus lbs or building muscle mass will determine which product to use. thanks for the great info!!

  25. Marissa Scott

    I didn’t realize IdealLean protein should be consumed within 30 mins of your workout. I thought it could be used throughout the day. Glad I learned this info today!

  26. Jennifer Wooderson

    I learned ideal lean meal replacement is the better choice for me because I’m active and I weight train. Thanks for the info!

  27. Amy Auger

    Ideal lean is a protein replacement, and cannot replace a meal because it lacks fat and carbs

  28. Sandi Hemann

    This is great. I need a full meal replacement shake for on the go! I learned that this has the carbs and fat I need to replace my meal! Great option. Thanks!

  29. Jenny Williamson

    The Idealshape MRS is for those wanting to loose 25+ pounds and the ideallean MRS is for those looking to tone.

  30. Ashley Avalos

    Love all this info, but still a little confused. I workout 6 days a week for 30-60 min doing a variety of weights and cardio based workouts. I do need to lose 20-25lbs. I like doing a shake post workout that fills me up so I’m not starving again in an hour. Is it best to use just protein or would the lean MRS be a good option?

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      Right after you workout you should take IdealLean Protein, because post-workout you don’t want a meal with much fat or fiber. Stick with protein and carbs post-workout, then you can take your Meal Replacement a little later when you need a quick/nutritious meal.

  31. Carolyn Moore

    These meal replacement shakes are made from all whole foods and have the right macros to sub for any meal! Such a great product!

  32. Misty Hess

    This article was very helpful in educating us on which product is to be used for specific goals and exactly how to use them.

  33. Stephanie Haymore

    I have always wondered what the difference between the ideal shake and ideal lean line was! Thanks for posting this and explaining!

  34. AImee Stowers

    I learned the regular shakes are for those starting out and the MRS are the ones you should should use if you’re already active.

  35. Britni Stowell

    Been on my fitness journey for a little over a year now. I really had no idea how important it is to have these necessary components in my diet. I was able to lose about 30 pounds on my own, with watching what I ate and taking exercise classes, but now I need to build muscle and tone. For the last couple months I had been trying so hard, but nothing seemed to change. Now after finding these products and learning about the different macro ratios I feel so much stronger and can definitely notice a difference. The other day someone took a picture of me doing some exercises and my triceps were so noticeable! Love being able to see some change and I’ve finally been able to start increasing my weight lifting limits without feeling so exhausted. I’ve been using the ideal lean protein and BCAAs!

  36. Katlyn Hardecopf

    Wow, I never realized that with regular exercise, you need to replace your carbs more! I had always been under the impression that most carbs are bad and you should stay away from them. Now that I know that with my workout regimen of trying to work out 6 days per week (and wanting to lose less than 25 pounds), I have been making the correct decision by purchasing IdealFit products!! THANK YOU for always clarifying and making sure we understand why these products are benefitting us 😊😊 I’m so happy that I found the Ideal program last year!

  37. Leonora costello

    I learned that when staying active your body uses more macros (fats, carbs, and protein) thus why this content is higher in the ideal lean MRS. It’s completely opposite of what I would’ve thought.

  38. Elizabeth Eidenschink

    Trainer Lindsey! When you’re working out moderately to vigorously, I learned from this blog that your body uses up your total fat and carb supply! If you don’t supplement enough of that back through your diet, your body will feed off your muscles! I didnt realize that I could potentially be one of those people doing your challenges, walking daily, and being a dancer! This showed me that ideal lean meal replacement would be a great option for those nights I need a quick supper to go teach dance and for breakfast quick in the morning!

  39. Laura Miller

    Love this! I’m fairly new to Ideal so this was very informative! I learned the difference between a protein powder and a meal replacement. Our bodies need more in a meal to stay healthy, and MRS does that!

  40. Shari

    I learned that all of the IdealLean proteins are low in fat and carbs.

  41. Kristie Roxburgh

    I had no idea that fats, carbs and protein were such a science! I used to drink weight loss protein shakes 2-3 times a day in lieu of actual nutrition. Ideallean and Trainer Lindsay have taught me the importance of macros and of the timing of your nutrients with your workouts! I currently take your ideallean protein as part of my recovery supplement regime but would love to try the MRS for when I am too busy to meal prep!

  42. Christine

    I learned that the Ideallean meal replacement shakes are for more active individuals.

  43. Brandi Scott

    Macros… Macros are definitely something I learned more about. I work out 6/7 days of the week doing HIIT and martial arts… and I actually drink your IdealLean Whey Protein every morning and after my workouts. I wish I would have taken this stuff when I was in the military, lol I ended up just buying cheaper stuff at Walmart…sigh. I’m struggling a bit to tone my stomach but I’ve learnee that the body breaks down molecules differently when you’re super active… so I need to be better about my macro intake 🙁

  44. Dayle

    Wow! Fantastic article! I learned that I have been doing this wrong. Will definately make adjustments and hopefully see results! Thank you!

  45. Diana Robeson

    After reading the blog I learned that I need to be using the IdealShake. I want to loose 25lbs and didn’t know what the difference was about all the shakes out there. This blog was very informative to me. Thank you

  46. Ashley Kees

    So informative! I had no clue that having more than 25lbs to lose I may be consuming too much protein! 😳

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      Hi Ashley, it will also depend on how active you are. If you are more active you generally want more protein, and if you aren’t as active you won’t need quite as much in relation to body weight. So if you are active you want around .9-1 g of protein per lb and if you are less active you may want around .6 g of protein per pound of body weight daily. Tracking your macros is the perfect way to make sure you have a balanced diet to help you reach your goals! Learn more here: https://www.idealfit.com/ultimate-guide-to-macros.list?widget_id=509755

  47. Kristin

    I didn’t realize there were two different meal replacement options as well as a whey protein. I’ve been using the whey for breakfast, but loooks like I need the idealshake meal replacement since I need to lose 30+ lbs. Is that right?

  48. Karen

    Wow I have been doing it all wrong. I was always using my high protein shakes as a meal replacer and found that i ate more because i was so hungry. Great read and very informative!

  49. Cecilia Ferreira

    I learned that I can DO IT, I can eat healthy and workout 😁
    You guys make everything so fun and delicious shakes.
    Thank you so much, you guys change my live, and learn to enjoy the way to eat healthy and have fun working out 🏋

  50. Laura

    This is a wonderful article. I def need Mrs! Strength and conditioning three days a week. I’m always stuck in the middle of a diet but wanting to make sure my body is getting enough of what it needs. I wold love to use this product and see how it helps my progress! I’ve never cared what the scale said and muscles are beautiful!

  51. Lisa Petersen

    Wow I feel like I learned so much. The meal replacement shake is for those who need to lose more or can’t workout at the moment. The lean shake isn’t supposed to take place of a meal but instead be used before or after a workout. The powder should be used to hit your macros each day. I loved the breakdown, as it helped me to see the difference. I feel confused often and overwhelmed so I end up not buying. This makes me feel like I could try them out. Thanks so much for the opportunity

  52. Michaela Sorvino

    Wow I loved reading the difference between the Ideallean meal replacement shake and the Idealshape meal replacement shake. I also didn’t realize that when you have a slow metabolism and a high-fat, high-carb diet, your gut struggles breaking down and utilizing foods which plays a role in insulin resistance and ultimately a slow metabolism. So exercise is important to overall health and fitness but replacing your “heavy” meals with a shake can help rebalance the gut to help your body start processing foods the way it was intended to. Thanks for always sharing great insight and tips.

  53. Donna

    I’ve been struggling to meet my weight loss goals since 2015. From reading this post I’m learning that idealshape mrs is best to lose more than 25lbs. I use both idealshape and ideal lean products but going to refocus and stick to the idealshape mrs unless I’m strictly following the 15 day fit body challenge. Thanks for always making information like this available to a novice like me.

  54. Brooke Eddy

    Love this blog! This shows how different supplements work with your daily activities. I love ideal lean because I live a very active lifestyle and need the extra protein to keep me going! Thanks Lindsey!

  55. Jill stewart

    Awesome post! I’ve been wondering which to use since I have more than 25 lbs to lose I guess I’ve got my answer!

  56. Lisa Van Hout

    I learned that people with a higher percentage of fat require less protein, which I never would have known! Very helpful article!

  57. Vanessa

    6 months ago I would never have know the difference with any of these products and since I came across idealfit on Facebook I have learned so much. The products taste great and I’m hooked on it all. Thank you for the great products and article!

  58. Daena

    Thank you for the article. I learned more about the difference in Ideal Shake, IdealLean MRS, and IdealLean protein powder. All great products but intended to be used in different ways. Knowing the difference helps you use them better.

  59. Kenne Bauer

    I have learned that if you have More ​25 or more pounds to lose the you need idealshape and if you have less and want to tone then idealfit is forever​. I also have learned that you can eat and to not freak out if you over do it, just get backon track and live and have fun!

  60. Jessica

    Thank you for the informative post! Ideal Fit has really helped me to learn the right amount of calories for my body. I’m not afraid of calories and I’ve lost 22 lbs since January! Protein has been so key, especially in muscle recovery.

  61. Madison Gramling

    I learned that the IdealFit Meal Replacement Shake (MRS) is higher in fat, protein, and carbs compared to the IdealShake. MRS is meant for those who need a healthy option for a meal but may not have had time to meal prep.

  62. Krista

    This article was actually super helpful and answered a question that I have had for some time now. I am quite new to the world of protein shakes and meal replacement shakes, and it seems that there is not enough information out there for beginners. This article put it into simple terms and made it clear what each one was for and even which one was the better option. I have googled that same question previously and got several less-than-helpful responses. With easier to understand information, I feel a lot more knowledgeable as I begin my own journey! Thank you!

  63. Amanda

    Thank you for the info on the difference between the two… it has shown me that I need idealshake first to drop the weight that o need to, then later on when I want to become more lean I can switch it up to the ideal lean mrs.

  64. Brooke Jorden

    This was so helpful! I have been using IdealFit protein for about 6 months, but it’s good to know that the MRS will still fit into my goals of maintaining muscle while replenishing the carbs and fat my body burns.

  65. Mary

    Great info! Here is what I learned …when you have a slow metabolism and a high-fat, high-carb diet, your gut struggles breaking down and utilizing foods. This the Dreaded belly that does not go away😒

  66. Marisa Pasquale

    Interesting article!! I wasn’t aware of how our body’s metabolic needs were different based on fitness levels! This article taught me a lot about dietary needs for me!

  67. Kelsey Wheeler

    I never knew the difference before starting Ideal Shake and Ideal Lean products, but now I do! Ideal Shake is for those waning to lose 25 pounds or more of body weight. Ideal Shake is for those with an active lifestyle like myself. Being on a ketogenic diet, I am making the switch to strictly Ideal Lean for now on.

  68. Tina Tupy

    Thanks for this information, it’s a great breakdown of which powder to use when! I currently use IdealShape as a meal replacement at lunch time and use Ideal Lean Protein as a part of my morning breakfast. Love these products and how they make me feel. Thank you!

  69. Chau Phan

    I learned that your body uses macros differently depending on if you’re active or not and your diet will depend on what your main goal is.

  70. Bree

    Wow! What a great article with wonderful information. I honestly didn’t know what each of these did for your body. After reading this I now know that I’ve been getting the wrong kind for where I am at in my fitness goals. Thanks a bunch for the info and making it so easy to understand!

  71. Angela Mignano

    I must admit I’ve heard wonderful reviews about your product but was waiting to h my current “stash”. Love the fact that you’ve covered all bases here. Eager to try !!

  72. Angie Pickering

    Awesome post!
    I learned that the Ideallean is best for pre & post workout supplement because it lacks the carbs and fats to make it a complete meal replacement.

  73. Victoria Johnson

    I learned about how the ideallean whey and MRS can both help me with my weight training and getting leaner goals

  74. Joy Stokes

    I think I need IdealLean MRS because it was created for those who are active and looking for healthy food options to add into their diet. Would love to try it or Ideal Shape, both would be amazing!

  75. Marissa

    Thank you so much for the clarification. It def helped with my confusion and gave me a more to think about. Thank you for the time and efforts you’ve put into this!

  76. Daisy Cortez

    I actually did not know the meal replacement can be used as an actual “meal replacement.” I sincerely thought it would just be a snack, like the protein shake. But now that I know, I’ll have to incorporate it as one of my meals.

  77. Alicia Howser

    I learned that I should be using the Ideal Lean MRS! This is so helpful.

  78. Samantha Y.

    I’m trying to lose weight after baby no. 2, I have been focusing on my workout routine & eating, but I’ve been making sure that my body has enough protein for fuel. I didn’t stop to think that I needed less protein to lose weight like the idealshake has! Good info!!

  79. Marissa Elizabeth

    Thanks. I am starting to count macros next week and looking for a protein shake to supplement my diet. I think I may use IdealShape MRS to start and then transition to IdealLean MRS or Ideal Lean Protein Powder once I get on track. This article helped!

  80. Christina

    This article was great in describing the difference between the three shakes. Ideal shape to lose weight and manage appetite. IdealLean protein to build muscle for an active lifestyle and taken before or after a workout. It doesn’t have fat or carbs while ideal lean MRS does making it a complete meal. I have uses IdealShape in the past and am currently using IdealLean protein but would love to try out the meal replacement!

  81. Tammy Arreola

    This blog is very informative and I appreciate how you’ve broken it down and made it understandable for anyone. I am a personal trainer/group fitness instructor and I’m getting ready to host a nutrition seminar for my clients so I’ve been brushing up on insulin resistance and metabolic syndrome which seem to be playing a huge role in the obesity factor these days.

    What is exceptionally valuable about this blog is the fact that you’ve distinguished between the two products based on goals. Knowing the macronutrient breakdown of each product and your explanation of when/why you should be utilizing the product is super helpful.

  82. Mariah

    This was such an interesting article! I didn’t know that those with a higher body fat content needed less fat and carbs. The science is fascinating! Also, if I’m understanding correctly, the Idealshake will help you lose weight because it has less carbs, less fat, and less calories. The Ideallean is meant as a meal when you’re already in shape because it has higher carbs and higher fat for muscle recovery! That’s amazing:) definitely ordering some when I start the 6 week challenge!

  83. Meredith C

    There is not a one size fits all routine and its great that we have options to meet our specific needs. Knowing the goals/outcomes will determine which type of shake to get. This article breaks it down perfectly and I know that I need to just use IdealLean Protein because I am already active and I just want to tone and build muscle. Getting enough protein for me is necessary to achieve the goals I want.

  84. Arianne

    Wow! This really helped. I just recently found out my metabolism is incredibly slow. No matter how hard I worked out, I was stuck between the same weight range. This week, I took some advice from a friend and changed up my diet and did things to improve my metabolism (like working out in the morning) and I definitely saw improvements! This blog helped me realize I need IdealShape because of how much I need to lose and my issues with a slow metabolism. Thanks for the info!

  85. Shelli

    What a great article! I now know the difference between the two replacement shakes. Because I am just working on toning and not losing weight, I know that the ideallean shake is for me. Thanks!

  86. Sabrina Overbey

    Glad I read this blog, I think I’ve been going about this protein shake backwards. Since I want to lose 30 pounds I should be drinking the IdealShape as meals instead of the IdealLean.

  87. Natalie

    Losing Losing weight and getting toned require different diets!? I just assumed it was the same.

  88. Patty Wallace

    Thank you, I learned the difference between the two meal replacement shakes.. if you looking to loose over 25lbs then Idealshake is better for you since it is lower in carbs, fats and protein. Idealfit MRS are for active people who are looking for healthy food options to add into their diet. This article has made things easier for me to decide. I currently have both, now I know when to use them 🙂

  89. Rachel

    From reading this article I learned that the ideal shape MRS would be the proper meal replacement shake for me as I do not need to lose more than 20-25 pounds, but the protein doesn’t have the correct macronutrients for a meal. Great article! Pick me for the sweepstakes!

  90. Amanda Kuester

    I learnt that with moderate daily exercise you expell all of your daily carb & fat supply. If you dont get enough-proper macros- your body will take the nutrients from your muscle supply! 😳

  91. Leann

    Love your products! I’ve tried several different IdealLean protein flavors, and there hasn’t been one I didn’t enjoy! I like the idea of using the MRS for those busy days when you can’t meal prep. I don’t always have my blender nearby to add in my carbs and fat to the protein powder, so I will definitely be looking into the MRS as another option.

  92. Brooklyn ross

    So ive been looking for a protein shake i actually like and i found it with idealfit because i actually cant taste the protein in it and thats why i would stop with the other shakes because they would be nasty…so ive been on ideal fit since January but havent been able to really work out since i had surgery on both my hands causing me to back track on my new life change goal…anyway i love idealfit shakes and all the support i get from all the ladies..but this next week im starting with the workouts but got to wait for my new tennis shoes so im excited about finding you guys and taking the step on trying ur products

  93. Jamie

    Thank you so much for this! I currently use the IdealLean Protein Powders but also need a MRS, and now I know IdealLean MRS is the choice for me!

  94. Amber

    I didn’t realize that if you have a higher body fat percentage, you require less protein. I have always been told the opposite. Great information!

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      Hi Amber, it depends on how active you are. If you are more active you need more protein, and if you aren’t as active you won’t generally need as much (in relation to your body weight)

  95. Johanna Messer

    This is awesome! So I just placed an order yesterday and added both protein powder and meal replacement shakes into my cart. Well low and behold I took one out of my cart because I thought there was no way that I needed both! After reading this article I now know I should have read this first haha. I thought they were sort of interchangeable and ether one could be used in place of the other. Now knowing the difference between the both, and knowing the difference between ideal lean shakes and ideal shape shakes, I think I know what I need to go REadd to my cart.

  96. Johanna Messer

    This is awesome! So I just placed an order yesterday and added both protein powder and meal replacement shakes into my cart. Well low and behold I took one out of my cart because I thought there was no way that I needed both! After reading this article I now know I should have read this first haha. I thought they were sort of interchangeable and ether one could be used in place of the other. Now knowing the difference between the both, and knowing the difference between ideal lean shakes and ideal shape shakes, I think I know what I need to go REadd to my cart.

  97. Jen

    There is so much useful information in this article. I am fairly active, but did not realize this causes my body to process nutrients differently. I know I need to be more mindful about my diet. This has always been the most difficult part of maintaining a healthy lifestyle for me.

  98. Dianne Carr

    I think the whey protein may be the best choice for me though I was looking for a meal replacement. Being a very active, semi athlete, over 220 lbs, still needing to drop 20+ lbs, as my goal. I toggle between needing the meal replacement for my very busy schedule and needing high protein to replenish after workouts. I do need a low fat option. Hopefully, I get a chance to try your products. Thanks.

  99. Rebecca Cheng

    For the contest😀 I would love to win the giveaway! I learned that if you are already active you require more fat carbs and protein to help with muscles. Ideal fit would be more beneficial to use than ideal shape 😀

  100. Kendall Szczerba

    Ideal lean whey protein is lower in fat carbs and protein in comparison to Ideal Lean MRS so it should be consumed right before or right after a workout to help rebuild muscles worked and then a full meal should be consumed 2-3 hours later. This type of protein is for those who want to tone and build muscle, not to lose 25 pounds like the Ideal Shape shakes.

  101. Laura

    Thank you for explaining the difference between the IdealLean MRS and IdealShape MRS! I love that you’ve created a MRS for the active individual who’s on the go, that can be used as a healthy food option when they need a quick meal or haven’t had time to meal prep and that still fits in their meal plan. Since I’m active and lifting 5-6 days a week, I now know which one is right for me – IdealLean MRS!

  102. Haley Searle

    Thank you for writing this and explaining the difference between the two! I am new to this product and felt like I wanted to try everything out and then decide what to really use daily, but after this article I realized which way to go! I have played soccer my whole life but had a baby and now am learning what it’s like to “lose weight”. I just want to get my core toned back to the prepregnancy state. I’m hopefull and excited to try IdealLean and hope it does just that– get me toned! I learned that this can also be a “healthy snack on the go”. I often miss a meal because I didn’t have time to prep something before I had to work or go somewhere. Thanks again- IdealLean is the thing for me 🙂

  103. Crystal B.

    This blog was very informative! Losing weight and gaining lean muscle are 2 different processes. I learned one (building muscle) requires more healthy fats, protein, and carbs. The other (losing weight) doesn’t require as much. Thank you for great info once again!!

  104. Chanieca

    This was very informative! Thank you! I think I will be switching to the ideal lean protein shake. I didn’t realize that I needed more protein in my diet to reach my goal.

  105. Bernadette Rynish

    Great article with so much info. I definitely didn’t know the difference between the two shakes! I have about 20 lbs to lose I work out 3-4 a week can I use either shake or would one be better for me over the other? Thanks!

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      You could use either one, but since you have less than 25 pounds to lose, IdealLean Meal Replacement Shake could be the way to go!

  106. Ashley

    Makes sense! Ideal lean sounds like the right fit for me as I don’t need to lose more than 25 pounds. I honestly didn’t even know there was a difference!

  107. Becky Brockman

    It was very helpful to understand the differences. I was a little confused when to use the Ideal Protein (just before or after training) versus the Meal Replacement (on the go). But when using the Ideal Protein after a workout, don’t you want some kind of carb to help with protein absorption? P.S. LOVE the recipe section!!!

  108. Tracie

    I love the ideallean protein powder! Thank you for explaining the difference from the meal replacement. I learned this may be the option I need to get all my meals in because I’m usually pressed for time.

  109. Destiny Larson

    This is a great post! I learned that you do have different macro needs when you are more athletic and ideal lean mrs is better for that than the idealshake mrs! I just can’t wait for you to come out with more yummy flavors of the lean mrs!

  110. Cindy Bober

    The IdealShake was created for individuals who are wanting to become active, or just starting a workout regimen and typically need to lose more than 25 pounds. This seems to be the shake I would need. Can’t wait to try it.

  111. Tara Dawson

    While I am very active, working out 4-5 times a week and work on my feet, this article makes me think that Ideal Shake is the right choice for me right now since I am trying to lose quite a bit of weight.

  112. Jody

    I love this article!! It breaks it down so easily so you can decide what what is best for you. I learned that the ideallean MRS is more for already active people who are looking to loose a little weight and tone up and so this is probably the line of products I should be using:)

  113. Angela R Irvin

    This was wondering what the difference was between lean and fit. Thanks for sharing this information.

  114. Misty Whitmore

    No one ever told me I didn’t need as much protein! In fact the lady I workout with told me I need more protein and less everything else!! No wonder I’m not loosing anything!!!😡😡 feeling frustrated! But this article opened my eyes on which products I need!

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      Hey Misty, it will also depend on how active you are. If you are really active you should be getting around .9 to 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight daily, but finding out what your macros should be specifically depending on your goals will be the best bet to help you reach your ideal weight. Here is a link to learn more about counting your macros: https://www.idealfit.com/ultimate-guide-to-macros.list?widget_id=509755

  115. Almira

    This is a great article! I learned so much I don’t even know where to start but I think the biggest thing I learned is that I should be drinking more ideallean MRS over idealshake MRS because I’m at my goal weight and am very active. I’d love to win a tub to start me off!

  116. Hillery

    I loved learning about the macros in the MRS. I need these to help when I need something just right to fit in with my macros for the day!

  117. Theresa

    What if we haveost 25 pounds but are not very active? Should 2e switch to ideallean meal replacement? I learned that people with higher body fat need less protein! I didn’t know that. Thanks for the article.

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      You also need less protein if you are less active. An active woman needs around 1 g of protein per pound of body weight daily, but if you aren’t as active you don’t need quite as much. Do you still have more than 25 pounds you want to lose? If so, you could move back to IdealShape!

  118. Lexi

    I didnt know that if your not getting enough nutrients your body need it will take from muscle.

  119. Shawnna Nixon

    I lrarned that the IdealShake is for those wantingbto lose more than 25# and the MRS is truly a meal replacement for when you cant prepare a meal. I would have thought it was the opposite. Thanks for clearing that up.

  120. Rita

    I’ve been mixing MRS and Protein, Now I won’t have too. Thanks you for making it easy, I wish you would add more flavors, like Mocha, Caramel and Mint.

  121. Erica

    I have been working out for almost a year and a half. I have lost 22 lbs over that time. I workout at least 3 times a week which include weights and cardio. I thought I needed to be using the muscle forming shake, but after reading this article I know I need to look into the idealshape. I still have at least 35-40 more lbs to work off. I do like the fact I can see muscle and my shoulders are more squared off than ever. Thank you for giving the explanation! Sometimes all the different options become overwhelming.

  122. Erin

    This is just the article I needed. Thank you for explaining the difference.

  123. Sydney Pong

    Giveaway Entry:

    I use both idealshake and idealfit meal replacement shakes. Definitely good to know the difference. I learned that the idealfit MRS is intended for more active women who do not have as much weight to loose. It has higher fat, carbs, and protein. Definitely what I personally need because I have reached my weight loss goal and need to build muscle too

  124. Gina

    I learned a little more on what I should be putting into my body. For so long I avoided adding more protein to my diet because I was afraid it would make me gain a lot of weight. However, I recently started adding the ideallean whey protein to my diet and have noticed a difference. I have more energy and after reading this I have a better understanding as to why. Love the breakdown of what each product does too. Really helpful and informing.

  125. Jennifer Greene

    I learned that Ideallean MRS was made for those who are active and looking for healthy food options to add into their diet. If we are regularly active then we need more carbs, protein, and fats to help with building lean muscle mass. As a person that weight trains this is the perfect option for me!

  126. Brittany

    I recently ordered the ideal lean meal replacement and I am loving it. I have a busy schedule during the day and this is an excellent go to for those hectic days. I have recently started counting my macros and this is defined helping me reach my fitness goals as I didn’t realize how much protein is needed. I have really enjoyed this blog of being able to tell the difference in which one you need and I am working on toning up and this seems to be a great fit for me.

  127. Carol Noll Reynolds

    Give away entry-

    I have lost a total of 50 lbs with the help of your products! Now that I’m at the point of toning my body the ideal lean products are great!! So I learned from reading this blog that if you exercise moderately to intensely you exhaust all your carbs and fat supply daily!! And that if your not getting the proper nutrients to replenish those through your diet your body will actually take the nutrients from your muscles!! 😳
    This is something I did not know until now!! Thanks for all your help to achieve my goals!! 💪🏻💪🏻

  128. Courtney

    Ideal Lean seems like it would be more appropriate for me since I do not have 25 lbs to lose, and I’m already active just looking to eat better.

  129. Tomi Jo

    IdealShake was created for individuals who are wanting to become active, or just starting a workout regimen and typically need to lose more than 25 pounds. Those who are less active generally require less protein, as their body fat to muscle ratio is skewed in favor of body fat.

  130. Jeni allen

    I appreciate knowing that the protein is more performance enhancement and how it differs for the meal replacement!! Love your products!!!

  131. Ramona Holley

    Thank you. I always struggle with what protein powder to use. I think I need to add the mrs to my diet since I am very active. I do have a question too-I have to stay away from lactose-sod whey proteins always have lactose in them?

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      IdealLean Protein contains approximately 0.375g of lactose per serving. If you are lactose intolerant or have any dairy-associated medical condition, please consult a physician before use. You can also try IdealRaw protein because it is plant based! https://www.idealraw.com/home.dept

  132. Stephanie carwell

    This is a great article. I finally learned the nutritional difference between Ideallean MRS and Idealfit MRS. It’s pretty simple to understand. Use Ideal lean if you have at least 25 lbs to lose and are just getting into working out. Use iIdealfit if you have a fitness regimen, little weight to lose and are trying to build muscle. I would love to try that idealfit MRS for my very busy days.

  133. Ashley Gordon

    I learned that people who are active need more carbs, protein & fats in their diet to help build muscle mass! That is why the ideallean MRS is best for those who are looking to tone, in contrast to those who have over 25-30 lbs to lose.

  134. Jodi Armstrong

    I was wondering what the difference between the 2 shakes was . this was so helpful to learn why depending on your fitness level you’d want one shake vs the other and what the benefits would be like higher protein for those already active and looking to lose less weight. I love learning the science behind products.

  135. Ashley Prettyman

    Never really knew there was different diets for weight lost or toning!

  136. Brittney Craig

    IdeaLean Whey Protein is recommended to use before AND after workouts. I thought it was just post workout. Good to know!

  137. Cali Filges

    I learned that I exhaust all my carbs and fat supply daily! Would love to win! Please pick me!!

  138. Shawna Cooley

    Losing weight and getting toned require different diets!? I just assumed it was the same. Thanks for all the information, will be reading more articles of yours

  139. Jessica Garcia

    Hi ! I learned that it is important to know and recognize if you’re an athletic person vs someone who is semi or less active because that can vary on the type of diet you need to be on. This is important to make sure you get the right amount of protein, carbs, fats etc to meet your goal! Great article.

  140. Laura tryon

    I didn’t realize we exhaust our carb and fat supply everyday. I want to try the MRS now! Thank you so much for all this information!

  141. Jen

    I hope I win because I learned that I need the meal replacement shakes to shed a few pounds and that the 3 macros are key…which is where I’ve been screwing up. These shakes would help me get to the place where all the protein I’ve got will start to work better–or be more visible😉

  142. Jessica Pace

    I learned that your body uses macros differently when you’re more active. High intensity exercise changes the form of the molecules that make up your healthy foods when they are broken down in your gut. So interesting!!

  143. Monica

    This article is great. Didn’t know the difference between all the proteins. So glad that it sounds like I picked the correct ones to use for myself. Love these amazing products to make me the athlete I am.

  144. Rachael

    I have never been over weight, just always had those few pounds to get rid of. Something many of us call, “skinny fat”.
    My main goal is to tone my body. There are so many products out there and it can be overwhelming especially for someone like me who has no idea what it all does. I love that IdealFit has so many products that cater to all types of women. I just ordered some BCAAS and I’m so excited to try them out!!

  145. Shelly Harris

    This was very helpful! I learned that for myself being a beginner and needing to lose a significant amount of weight that the Idealshape shake is best for me right now. I’m going to set a goal to graduate to the Ideallean in future!❤

  146. Bianca Juarez

    I learned the difference between Idealshake && Idealean. I now know what I need in order for me to tone up. I can use this product and it will help me out while being active. It won’t be a replacement meal but it could help me when I can not make a meal.

    I also learned that Idealwhey will work with Ideallean because it helps replenish my muscles as in it will help my muscles relax and become less tense from a high intense workout. This will also help relive the tension of the muscles.

    This article did help me discover what I did need in order for me to help my body maintain the progress I accomplish.

    Thank you.

  147. Bianca Juarez

    I learned the difference between Idealshake && Idealean. I now know what I need in order for me to tone up. I can use this product and it will help me out while being active. It won’t be a replacement meal but it could help me when I can not make a meal.

    I also learned that Idealwhey will work with Ideallean because it helps replenish my muscles as in it will help my muscles relax and become less tense from a high intense workout. This will also help relive the tension of the muscles.

    This article did help me discover what I did need in order for me to help my body maintain the progress I accomplish.

    Thank you.

  148. Brittany Pekuri

    I love ideal for! The products taste great and Lindsey’s workouts are amazing.

    When your metabolism is slow and you eat a high carb high fat diet your gut has a harder time breaking down the fat.

  149. Sheena

    This is amazing. I would definitely chose the shake as its lower in fat, which if you are trying to lose weight, is best.
    I love these products. I believe they work especially since I am trying to lose ‘baby fat’.
    Perfect for after a workout at the gym

  150. Amber

    Thank you for this article. I would have went straight for shake, but since I’m active and wantIng to lose around 15lbs I’m going to try lean. It’s good to know how our body breaks down fat and carb intake, and definitely don’t want to pull from muscle we have already built! 🙂

  151. Amy

    Thank you for explaining each product! I’ve been trying to decide which product I need. Now I know!!

  152. Caitlin De Backer

    *Competition entry *
    I am astounded. Looking for the right protein shake for a woman who either is looking to lose weight or tone up is so difficult as most are high in carbs, calories and refined sugars. And most don’t help you achieve what you want. When you think of the term “protein shake” you don’t expect it to be unhealthy, right ? Well after extensive research trying to find the best protein shake for me, I came across Idealfit. In all honesty, I was hesitant and it sounded too good to be true but ladies this stuff is amazing and works so good !
    I learned from Idealfit that you need protein to sustain a good weight and to build muscle !
    Winning this would help me achieve my goals of losing weight that I have struggled with for years while knowing that I am fueling my body with a quality product that will assist me to achieve the body I am working so hard for before returing home to surprise my friends and family in South Africa ! Thank you thank you thank you for teaching us about nutrition and that it can be yummy while healthy !

  153. Peggy Bigoness

    Good to know. I workout Everyday so just use the ideallean.

  154. Angie

    This article is great! It’s so informative and breaks everything down – I’ve shared it with friends who ask why I use what I do.
    Re reading this again, I’m almost ready to switch as I’ve lost 20lbs and have less than 25 to get to my goal 😀

  155. Kris Braun

    I’ve ordered several flavors of the shakes and absolutely LOVE them! Great flavor and they keep you feeling full. I like tge flavored drink packets too, especially when i need that little boost to get me through the afternoon.

  156. Jen

    Because i workout regularly and hate cooking, the MRS is best for me and my body because macros are used differently when you’re active. Moderate to high-intensity exercise actually changes the form of the molecules that make up your healthy foods when they are broken down in your gut. Love this product and even more, the brand!

  157. Vanessa

    You need ideallean meal replacement if you workout a lot. Because of this you need more protein and carbs, which makes ideallean meal replacement the one for you!!

  158. Carina Woykin

    What a great article. I am definitely bookmarking this. Can men use ideal lean? Right now we both use ideal shape but sounds like we both would benefit with ideal lean. Thoughts?

  159. Kimberly

    I’m so glad I read this article as it cleared up so much! I’m sort of in the middle of using both of these, as I have a significant amount of weight to lose but am rather active – lots of walking and exercise. I feel like the IdealLean MRS would be a nice thing to try as I’m doing a lot more weight training. I truly love these products as they have made such a world of difference for me!

  160. CHELSEY B

    This article was really helpful. I didn’t know the difference. The MRS shake is for those of us (ME!) who need to lose 25 pounds or more. The protein powder is for those who are active.

  161. Jacqueline

    IdealLean would be perfect for me since I only want to tone up and not lose more weight. It would be great for days that I’m in a rush and don’t have any meals prepared! Would love to win a sample and try it out! Thanks!

  162. Diana Pontes-washtock

    Ideal lean helps to do exactly that lean out. Which is what I am trying to achieve and it will supply the correct amount of data, carbs and proteins to support my body.

  163. Kelsey

    Thanks so much for this article! I believe the article breaks it down as people looking to lose more than 25 pounds, are just becoming active or starting a workout program should be choosing idealshape meal replacement shakes. And those who are already active, and looking to build lean muscle mass and add more options into their diet should choose ideallean meal replacement shakes.

    Thanks again for the clarification!

  164. Belinda Chappell

    Very informational. I use the idealfit protein for my recovery and meal replacement for meals or snack

  165. Tammy steele

    I live your programs and blog very informative I have done MRS before but yours are healthier thanks for showing the difference

  166. Karla

    Meal Replacement shakes are for individuals who need to loose 25 + pounds . Less carbs less sugar. Ideal lean is for active individuals who need more carbs and sugar while working out .

  167. Rebecca Rowell

    Idealshape is for some one who has 25 lbs or more to loose who is not active, ideal leans is for some who what to get in shape works out moderately to intensive with weights. I deal lean MRS is for muscle recovery can be taken before or after a workout .
    I do take another product at this time. It had worked for me, I have currently lost 66 lbs on it, I have increased my protein intake as I do work out about 5-6 days a week with weights. I love your Green Apple BCAA I drink it during and after my workout. I also take Idaellean fat burner teice a day.

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      Congrats Rebecca! That is amazing. Keep up the good work.

  168. Elsy Hernandez

    This is great information! I am working to lose 20-30 lbs so can I use either? It was good to get informed of the difference and what we need to reach our weight goals. I do workout 4-5 days a week for at least 45 min. Would love to enter the sweeps.

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      You could use either! But IdealLean products may be the way to go for you since you are so active, and the more active you are the more protein you need!

  169. Caitlyn

    So grateful for this article! Since I’m active and eat healthy, I should probably make the switch to this MRS instead of Ideal Shake, since I’m using up more fat and carbs than I realized. (And this could explain why I’ve hit a plateau recently. Not getting the right amount of macros!)

  170. AW Hendrix

    Great information on how each product works for specific needs. Most people just assume less calories/more exercise means weight loss and don’t expect to need more protein later on as muscle starts building.

  171. Erica Liggins

    I need idealshape meal replacement but I hope to one day get to the point where I switch to ideallean! Idealshape is to aid in losing weight like 25+ pounds. Ideallean aids in toning muscle and maintaining. Both still require a healthy diet and exercise in the combination though.

  172. Teressa

    So the Ideal Lean Mrs is more for those who are already exercising regularly and shouldn’t be used as a meal replacement if I am understanding it correctly? I am currently following a macro based diet given to me by a personal trainer and am doing some weight training and cardio. I lost 4 lbs the first week and have gained 1 lb back in the 3 weeks following. I’m not sure which product would be best for me. I feel like I need something to give me a jumpstart.

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      So the IdealLean Meal Replacement Shake CAN be used as a meal replacement! IdealLean Products would be the best for you, and you can try one of our free challenges which is perfect for jumpstarting your fat loss and lean muscle goals! Check them out here: https://www.idealfit.com/idealfit-challenges.list

  173. Mel O

    IdealLean MRS is a great alternative for individuals that are active and looking for healthy food options to add into their diet, since they need more carbs, protein, and fats. It helps with building lean muscle mass; especially those who weight train.

  174. Breezy

    It sounds like I should try to use ideal lean since I workout 5-6 times a week with hiit workouts and weights. Most of the time I struggle trying to eat enough and so it might slow down my metabolism.

  175. Tawny

    Great article! Great info on comparing the different products and which ones you need for a active lifestyle vs starting out in fitness. Look forward to trying the idealean to tone!

  176. Claudia

    I was confused on which product to buy. I wasn’t sure if the ideal lean or ideal shape was what is missing from my exercise regimen. Thanks for posting this article!

  177. Marcia Beck

    This article was awesome! Thank you so much for explaining the differences I was wondering about! I am going to stick with IdealShake for now until I get these 25lbs off and then once I get more active I will switch to the IdealLean MRS to really tone up!

  178. Sharri Calderon

    The IdealLean MRS is for people who are active and looking for healthy food options to add to their diet. People who are more active require more carbs, protein, and fats to help with building lean muscle mass. IdealShape is for people who are just starting to get active who don’t need as much protein and have 25+lbs to lose.

  179. Caite

    Very helpful! Glad to know the difference and that those who are already very active should be using the ideallean me a option.

  180. Jodi Flick

    Thank you for clearing up the difference between each shake. I have been drinking the idealshake for sometime thinking that lower fat, carbs, ect….would help me lose weight. I do not need to lose 25 pounds, I technically should be using the ideallean meal replacement shakes and the whey powder. I am actually waiting on my shipment from idealshape for meal replacement shakes, ugh, I would love to win this prize to switch over to ideallean. Especially now that I know I should be using ideallean instead of idealshape……moneywise I can’t afford to order now since I just ordered from idealshape. Please pick me!!!!

  181. Lori

    This article is amazing. I’d been wondering the difference. Thank you. If I was already a healthy eater & wanting to start toning I would use IdealLean MRS.

  182. jennifer Sepull

    People who are not very active and trying to lose more than 25 lbs should use ideal shake Mrs
    And people who are more active should use the idealfit Mrs to help with building lean muscle.

  183. Carley Overman

    I learned that when you have a slow metabolism and a lot of fat and carbs in your diet, your gut has a hard time breaking down and utilizing foods. This is when the Idealshakes can be helpful.

  184. Carley Overman

    I learned that when you have a slow metabolism and a lot of fat and carbs in your diet, your gut has a hard time breaking down and utilizing foods. This is when the Idealshakes can be helpful.

  185. Chelon Colquitt

    This article was so informative. I ordered the Idealfit protein and am waiting to receive it. I am so excited to try it…but after reading this article, I might need to try the MRS too. Thanks so much for sharing!

  186. Cindy edwards

    I have been using ideal shape for over a year now and also use ideal lean protein. I love both products but I am down to having 20 pounds to loose. I need the ideal lean MRS .
    I think it would help me get to my ideal weight.

  187. Mary Anne

    Thank you so much for this article that explained the difference. It can be so confusing. I love the idealfit meal replacement shake and that’s what I needed to be taking! Thank you so much!!

  188. Jess

    Great article. I wish I would have known all of this before I just ordered though. Sounds like the idealshake is what I need at this moment. Not the lean like I have. I thought I had done my research.

  189. Michelle Siwert

    This was very helpful to learn the difference between these supplements. I use IdealLean’s whey isolate and absolutely love it. I would be interested to try the meal replacement shake, but I’m a little hesitant because I typically don’t like shakes with whey concentrate.

  190. Maxine Dewey

    This was very imformative and I learned alot reading your blog. Thanks for the information.

  191. Colette

    I didn’t realize the differences between the two shakes…. that IdealShape meal replacement shakes are better for those wanting to lose 25+ pounds, while IdealLean meal replacement shakes are for those who are already active and want to tone.

  192. Tammy Key

    Give away entry-
    Thanks! I have often wondered the difference in the 2 products.
    I have been using the IdealFit Protein powder and have hit my goal weight but now I would like to tone. I was debating about the meal replacement shakes. They just seemed to have so much more carbs and I wasn’t sure why…now I understand better.

  193. Cindy

    Thanks for the explanations, I’m still not really sure which product to use??? I’ve been using the ideallean, but my goal is to lose about 20 pounds. I’m pretty active. I run at least 4 days a week totally 25-40 miles per week and do 4 marathons and a couple ultra marathons a year as a recreational runner. I usually do light weights and flexibility workouts 2x per week. Also, I’m 54 years old, not sure if there’s a shift in needs as we age?

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      It sounds like you are doing great Cindy! I recommend sticking with IdealLean because of your goals! But if you feel like you need more guidance, I recommend talking to your doctor as he will know better which will work for you!

  194. Veronica

    I am so eager to get srtaed!
    Please pick me to win my first ideal lean meal replacement !!!

  195. Jess

    I didn’t realize that you had 3 unique protein that drink products and what benefits each have.

  196. karen

    I own all 3 ( idealshake, mrs and whey protein) . My lifestyle is not consistent and finding time to work out varies each week. I have started and stopped or rather got off track a couple of times. However, I have lost 15 lbs with 20 to go. On a slower week when I workout 2 ( maybe 3) times , I use IS for breakfast and whey protein after workouts including “sensible” meals between. On more discipline weeks (workout 5-6 times), I use MRS and whey protein after workouts with more protein snacks and sensible meals. All the products taste good and are convenient. Any suggestions for improvement?

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      Sounds like you are doing great! Yes definitely! I recommend signing up for a 15 Day Challenge! They are free and include meals plans, workouts, and support! They are designed for quick fat loss, and lean muscle growth, and so many women have seen great results with them! You can check them all out here: https://www.idealfit.com/idealfit-challenges.list

  197. Maegan Williamson

    It’s great to know the difference now. I need to purchase IdealShake. I’ve struggled so bad losing the last 20lbs. I’m excited to start my new healthy journey with Lindsay’s guidance. 🙂

  198. Rachel Rinderknecht

    What an awesome giveaway! Ideallean would be the best for me because my focus is in building muscle. 🙂

  199. Elizabeth Rowe

    Wow! I learned that Ideal Lean MRS is for me as I am actively lifting and have less than 25 pounds I’d like to shed. Having some on hand for when on the go or caught unprepared!

  200. Tina Bradford

    Ideal shake for me…. I want less carbs due to diabetes… idea lean has the higher carbs, 20g… although I don’t need to loose 25 or more pounds…. I do need to tone up, I might try ideal lean for morning or afternoon shakes… thanks for the information…

  201. Ashley Orcutt

    Great read. Learned the difference between the two and that ideallean is more for those wanting to stay active and add healthy choices to their diet.

  202. Cory Coleman

    I understand the difference in shakes. Protein as a supplement, idealshape for losing 25+, and ideallean MRS for a meal if I’m working on keeping my strong lean body. My question is what is “active” ? I have been using the 15 day challenge workouts daily, and I’ve done 6weeks of the 12 week program. But previously I did crossfit, so these workouts are not as long or intense. Do you consider doing ONLY the ~20 min workouts 6 days a week “active” enough that I should use idealean MRS? ( I could totally still lose 25 pounds- but my heart is more into focusing on my health and strength than the number)

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      Yes, that is active enough to use IdealLean MRS, since your focus is more on your health and strength we definitely recommend using IdealLean products!

  203. Julie

    Excellent! Thanks for clarifying the whole thing… I was hoping you’d offer this detailed explanation & boom 💥, you did!
    Now I realize that my major weight loss that I began concentrating on last year with Ideal slake meal replacement that then lead me to switch in the fall to IdealLean whey protein was the exact fit for me& knowing more now in this toning stage, is exactly what I needed.
    Thanks again… what a great, delicious way for me to keep weight off & help this 50 year old Hot- body, toned, fit & healthier

  204. Carrie Loar

    I appreciate the informative breakdown of your products. After reading, I should be using the protein shake as a pre & post workout option. That’s definitely good to know! I think I may be checking out the Ideallean MRS as well to aide in supplementing.

  205. Nelfa Bice

    Thank you for the information. Here’s what I learned: The Idealshake was created for individuals who are wanting to become active, or just starting a workout regimen and typically need to lose more than 25 pounds. Those who are less active generally require less protein, as their body fat to muscle ratio is skewed in favor of body fat. It has lower in fat (2.5g), lower in carbs (10g) and, lower in protein (11g).

    While the IdealLean Whey Protein Powder is specifically a performance supplement. This means it should be used as a pre and post-workout snack to replenish your muscles in order to build them. Because it is strictly a protein supplement, it lacks the carbs and fats needed to make it a complete meal.

    The IdeaLean Whey Protein is: Low in fat (0g), low in carbs (0g) and, high in protein (20g) which I like so much compared to other brands. So, so good!

    My first two weeks of the 15 day BFC, I lost 9 lbs; yes, Lindsey did this to me! Good thing! My son is buying me two tubs of Ideallean protein and I’m getting the Idealshake replacement meal! Ha! So thankful!

  206. Kathleen Cellery

    Thank you for posting this article, I myself wasn’t sure the difference! Ideal shape is for woman who need to loose weight 25 pounds of more.ideal fit is for woman who do not need to loose a lot of weight but good protein to help lean up and build a stronger you.Thank you so much for explaining!

  207. Jennifer S

    Give away

    The Idealshape MRS is for those wanting to loose 25+ pounds and the ideallean MRS is for those looking to tone.

  208. Gabby

    Hi, I am trying to loose 10 pounds from my stomach I wanted to know what product is better for me. I currently go to the gym 4 times a week for about an hr-1.5hrs, sometimes I do weights, sometimes I do cardio, what would be recommended.

  209. Lisa

    I am still a little confused. I have and still do workout 5 times a week pretty intensely. However I still have 100 lbs to lose so it seems the meal replacement is still my best bet but not sure.

    1. Caitlin Peterson

      Yes, Meal Replacement Shakes are super beneficial! Since you workout so much, you could take either IdealLean MRS or IdealShake, but because IdealShake is lower in calories, carbs, fat, etc. you might want to take that one!

  210. Maggie

    Ideal Lean MRS shakes are for those who are active or weight lifting. They are best for those people because they are higher in protein carbs and fat so that the body does not take from the muscles that are being created. I actually was wondering which one was best for me before reading this article I see I may need the Ideal Shape MRS.

  211. Stephanie Finn

    I learned that your body uses macros differently if your body is active or inactive

  212. Kimberly vander meulen

    I love to try idealFit
    I learned it’s low fat high protein to lose weight

  213. Libby

    I wish I would’ve had this when I started my weight loss journey. I went straight for the protein but also tracked my macros. Thanks to Ideal lean products I have now lost 87lbs and am now grinding for my dream of abs. I am using the ideal protein, bcaas, pre workout, and fat burner to reach them! Thank you for the info and the inspiration 1.5 years ago I am a healthier happier mom, wife, and soon to be nurse.

  214. Rachael Lee Wright

    Give away entry –

    I learned I was consuming way too much protein ( currently on a low carb / keto diet) and not exercising nearly enough for fat loss. I ordered ideal fit protein a few days ago and am still waiting for my order to try it, so excited!

  215. Charlene Rice

    I learned that in order to order the right product you need to know what your goal is. If you want to lose weight then you need a mesl replacement shake not just a protein shake.

  216. Stephany Mulero

    I already knew the difference for each ideal line. But what impressed me the most and I’ve learned from it, is having a high-fat, high-carb diet, the gut struggles creating insulin resistance and having issues breaking down the food thus slowing the metabolism. Also how nutrients can be taken from muscle supply if the body is not maintained according to activity level.

  217. Debbie Tidwell

    This was very informative. It’s good to know that as soon as I hit my goal of losing 25 lbs that I can then start on the Ideal Lean MRS. Right now though, I’m totally enjoying my Ideal shakes. Thank you for explaining the differences to us all.

  218. amanda prata

    I need this as someone who needs to lose 85 pounds but also as someone who needs enough fuel to continue to train for 1/2 marathons. 🙂

  219. Patricia

    Thanks for all the incredible information! I love working out and am always looking for more information to improve my workouts and nutrition plan. I would love to slim down just a touch so I can see the muscles I know are already there.

  220. Amanda Heinrichs

    I just wanted to comment to possible win some goodies!

    The people who need IdealLean MRS are people who are moderately to intensely active, and those looking to tone up. This is because active people burn through their carbs and fats faster, and the MRS from IdealLean is an awesome replacement when you are on the go or forgot to meal prep 🙂

  221. Amy

    I am doing weight watchers and I am down 46 lbs. I am noticing the more weight I lose I am deflating. I am a waitress so I am active the whole time I work. I usually get 10,000 steps 3-4 days a week. I was drinking another brand of shakes during the day when I needed to eat but didn’t have the time. Is lean or shape a better option for me?

    1. Alyson McDonald

      Hi Amy, congrats on your weight loss so far that is awesome!

      As for which type of MRS is better for you, it depends what exactly you are wanting to accomplish with them.

      IdealShape MRS are great for weight loss, and help to curb your cravings for up to three hours to help you stay feeling full and avoid snacking in between meals more than is necessary.

      IdealLean MRS are packed with a unique blend of complex carbohydrates and fiber to help support hunger control to help you feel full. IdealLean MRS also provides a whey protein blend to keep your body feeling happy and given the nutrition it needs to build strong, lean muscle!

      I hope this info helped, please let me know if you have any other questions!

  222. Jocelin

    Hello all, I was wondering if there is a meal plan that incorporates the meal replacement shakes? I purchased the MRS but would like some guidance… Thanks!

    1. Christine Sanelli

      Yes there are! If you purchased the IdealLean meal replacement shake then take a look at the free 15 day challenges! If you are doing IdealShape then there is the IdealPlan (which has the full meal plan). There is also a free 15 day challenge for IdealShape!
      Free challenge for IdealShape:
      E-book Meal Plan IdealShape:
      Free Challenges Idealfit:

  223. Nancy

    Can i used both? Ideal shape mrs for breakfast and ideal lean mrs after my workout?

  224. Sarah

    Hi! I’m only 5’2 but I weigh 160lbs, alot of which i understand is muscle (I like an 8 if that helps figure sizes) so although I do wish to lose the last of my fat I’m not certain an actual lb amount. So in the mornings I usually drink an Idealshape Shake (I usually don’t have time for breakfast since I prefer to sleep alittle extra). I work out everyday from 20 min to 2hr with a mixture of weight and cardio. After workouts I usually drink my Idealfit protein shake. However, I recently saw that Idealfit also has a Meal Replacement Shake. I was debating on whether or not to add this to my diet (say as dinner) and have a normal lunch. Would this be okay or should I just stick to Idealshape or switch over all together?

    1. Christine Sanelli

      Since your goal is to lose weight, I would suggest staying with IdealShape as it’s formulated for weight loss. The Fit meal replacement shake is not necessarily formulated for weight loss, but to help you get in a meal with sufficient macros when you’re short on time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *